← All Seed News

One Field, One Year: What Your Harvest Results Can Settle and What They Cannot

One field in one season is one result, not a verdict. How much weight this fall's corn harvest results should carry, what to check before you repeat or drop a hybrid, and what to record about each field so the result can be explained.

One field in one season is one result, not a verdict. Weigh results across fields and across seasons, and keep a record of what was different about each field, so the result can be explained before it changes next year's corn plan.

That holds whether a hybrid came in strong this fall or fell short. Here is what one year can tell you, where it runs out, and what to check before a single harvest moves the call in either direction.

What one field in one year can settle

It settles what happened: how one hybrid yielded on one field, farmed one way, in one kind of year. That is a real result, and it is worth keeping.

What it cannot settle on its own is whether the same hybrid fits that field in a different year, or fits the field next to it. Nobody knows what kind of year next season will be, so one season's result speaks for one kind of year.

This season makes the point. DTN reported in August that western Indiana came close to 20 inches of rain in June, and Purdue corn specialist Dan Quinn told DTN there was variability even within individual counties. Then September ran dry: preliminary National Weather Service numbers show 2.13 inches at Lafayette and 1.19 at Terre Haute, both below normal. A result from this fall carries that year with it, and the field next door may have had a different one.

Read that way, one year is good at raising questions: where to look closer, what to ask about, and which result needs an explanation before it goes into next year's plan.

What changes the call: a single result is about to decide a field, or a hybrid, before anyone has asked what was different about that field or that year.

Why a neighboring field can give a different answer

Fields that sit close together can still differ in soil, fertility, nitrogen and how they are farmed, and a hybrid that suits one field or one operation may not suit another. That is why placement matters here, and it is also why results from neighboring fields do not always line up.

What to check when neighboring fields disagree:

  • Did the soil differ between the two fields?
  • Were fertility and the nitrogen plan the same on both?
  • Were they farmed the same way this year?
  • Was it the same hybrid on both, or are you comparing different hybrids on different fields?

That last question matters whenever you compare hybrid results across fields. When two hybrids sat on two different fields, the comparison carries every difference between those fields along with it. The gap may say as much about the fields as about the hybrids.

What changes the call: the difference between the results lines up with a difference between the fields. Then the field is the first explanation to rule out, before the hybrid.

Read across fields and across seasons before you change the call

Indiana Specialty Group does not want a seed plan to bet the whole farm on one product or on one year, and it puts weight on consistency across seasons. Nobody knows what kind of year is coming. One season shows how a hybrid handled the year it got; a record across seasons shows how it holds up when the years differ.

What to check:

  • Is this fall's result in line with how the hybrid has done in other seasons, or out of character?
  • Did the result show up on more than one field, or only one?
  • Where it showed up on more than one field, were those fields alike, or did they differ from each other?

What changes the call: the same result shows up across fields that differ and across seasons. That carries more weight than one strong or weak field in one fall.

Record what was different, not only what came off the field

A result does not explain itself. A note on what was different about each field is what lets you, and whoever plans with you, explain the result later and decide whether it belongs in next year's plan.

For each field, worth writing down while you are still in the field:

  • which hybrid was on it;
  • anything about the soil that sets it apart from the fields around it;
  • the fertility and nitrogen plan, and whether it changed from the usual;
  • how the field was farmed this year, and anything done differently;
  • what kind of year that field had, including its rainfall if you keep a gauge;
  • what you want to ask about the result before it moves next year's plan.

The point is to keep the reason next to the result, so it is still there when the plan is confirmed. If a partner or the next generation keeps the harvest records, this is the list to hand them.

A hybrid that did well: what to check before you repeat it

A strong result invites more acres. Before it gets them, check:

  • Did it do well on more than one field, or on one?
  • Are the fields you would move it to like the fields where it did well, in soil, fertility, nitrogen and how they are farmed?
  • What does its record look like in other seasons?
  • Would putting it on more fields put more of the farm on one product?

What changes the call: the strong result came from one field in one year, and the plan now puts that hybrid on fields that differ from it. Repeating it where it fits is one decision. Spreading it across the farm on the strength of one fall is another.

A hybrid that did not: what to check before you drop it

A disappointing field is also one result. Before it takes a hybrid out of the plan, check:

  • Was it placed on a field it fits?
  • Was something about that field different this year: fertility, the nitrogen plan, how it was farmed?
  • How did it do on other fields and in other seasons?
  • What role did it play in the mix, and what would dropping it do to how the plan spreads risk?

This fall's kind of year may or may not come again. Nobody knows, which is why one season makes a thin case for dropping a hybrid, the same as it makes a thin case for adding acres.

What changes the call: it fell short across fields that differ from each other and across seasons, not only on one field this fall. That is a different conversation from one disappointing harvest.

Carry the results into the seed conversation

At Indiana Specialty Group, harvest observations and confirmation visits are part of October and November in the seed year, so this fall's results can come into the conversation while the plan is being confirmed.

Bring the record, not only the result: what was different about each field, which results you would keep, which would change something, and which you want to question.

Then ask the recommendation to show its reasoning. How were this fall's results weighed against other fields and other seasons? Why does each choice fit its field? A recommendation should be able to answer both.

What changes the call: the recommendation treats one season as the verdict, or promises the best corn under every condition. Ask for the reasoning behind it.

If you want to go through this fall's results field by field before next year's plan is set, talk with our team.

Have a field in mind?

Tell us what you’re seeing. We’ll talk through what it could mean for your seed plan.

Talk with your local specialist